City of Madison Logo
Alder Ledell Zellers

Alder Ledell Zellers

Home Address:
510 N Carroll St
Madison , WI 53703

Phone: 608-417-9521
Common Council Office:
210 Martin Luther King, Jr. Blvd
Room 417
Madison, WI 53703
Phone: (608) 266-4071
Fax: (608) 267-8669
WI Relay Service

Proposed demolitions of 121, 123, and 127 W. Gilman to Construct Three Apartment Buildings

November 8, 2013 1:08 PM

One House Proposed for Demolition and One House Proposed to Be Moved

One house in the Mansion Hill Local Historic District identified as contributing to the Mansion Hill National Register Historic District is proposed for demolition to build an apartment building. The house, located at 127 W. Gilman (Jabez & M.B. Smith House), was built in 1896.  The house proposed to be moved, also identified as a contributing building, located at 123 W. Gilman (Benaiah Warnes Rental House), was built in 1886. It is proposed to be relocated to 113 W. Gorham.  The National Register of Historic Places documentation for the Mansion Hill District can be found:


The National Park Service defines a contributing building as one which adds to the historical integrity that makes the historic district significant.

In addition, the Highlander Apartment Building, located at 121 W. Gilman Street is proposed for demolition.

The houses proposed for moving and demolition are:


Downtown Plan and the Mansion Hill Neighborhood

The Downtown Plan, adopted in 2012, has a section about the Mansion Hill Neighborhood on page 55.  The Downtown Plan can be found at:

Both the objective for the neighborhood and one of the three recommendations relate to this proposed project.  They are:

Objective 4.10:  Mansion Hill's historic character is a major asset and establishing a "complete historic district experience" of restored buildings, distinctive streetscape amenities, and a limited amount of new residential development that preserves and reflects these historic attributes should be pursued.

Recommendation 98: Rehabilitate existing housing while encouraging selective residential infill.

City Ordinances Regarding the Mansion Hill Local Historic District

The Mansion Hill Local Historic District has specific criteria in Section 33.19(10) of the city ordinances. There are also standards for demolitions in historic districts in 33.19(5)(c). 

In considering whether to approve a demolition one consideration of the Landmarks Commission is whether the building "contributes to the distinctive architectural or historic character of the District as a whole".  The Mansion Hill Local Historic District was "designated [as an historic district], and protected because of its special character and historical interest."  The Landmarks Commission "in all matters regarding the issuance of Certificates of Appropriateness [i.e. permission to demolish or alter a building] shall act to work in the best interests of the existing structures in the Historic District and in cooperation with the applicant in developing sympathetic and original new structures.

Proposed Apartment Buildings

The buildings proposed for this site are three five-story apartment buildings with a total of 59 units. The proposal is by Steve Brown Apartments. The proposed buildings would be clad in brick and stone. As currently conceived the proposal is:


You can find additional information about the demolitions and development proposal at:


Neighborhood Meeting

A neighborhood meeting will be held on Thursday, November 21, 2013 at 7:00 pm at Madison College, 211 N. Carroll St, Room D240.  I encourage interested residents and others who care about this special area of our city to come to the meeting to learn more and share your thoughts about the proposed development. 

There will be an informational presentation about the project at the Landmarks Commission on November 11 (4:45 pm in room LL-110 of the Madison Municipal Bldg.)  No decisions will be made at that meeting.  Another Landmarks Commission meeting is scheduled for November 25 at the same time and location.  I expect decisions related to the proposed demolitions and construction to be made at the meeting on November 25.  Testimony at this meeting is welcome.

You can also email me or send comments to the Landmarks Commission ( ).  

Thank you.


Email to a friend Email to a friend

Subscribe to Email List

Subscribe to the Alder Zellers, District 2 email list:

Liquor License
Neighborhood Information
Neighborhood Meeting
Redevelopment/Development Proposal Meeting