Sauk Creek Greenway Restoration
8 Trees Planned for Removal in Spring 2021 based on Private Property Damage Concerns
City Engineering Operations plans to remove 8 trees adjacent to 25 Brule Circle between the access path and property line (see attached). There are 2 trees (tag #4606 and #4584) that are at risk of falling and damaging private property.
Tree #4583 is a ~26” diameter white oak, with many high dead limbs, and a large hole at the base of the tree showing root collar decay. In order to safely remove tree #4583, and protect adjacent, healthier, oaks, the City will need to remove 1 box elder tree (#4586) that has a wound on its trunk, 1 dead white oak (#4587) and 1 small un-tagged tree.
Tree #4606 is a box elder that is leaning aggressively over the fence. To access #4606 for removal, 2 dead invasive buckthorn (#4607 and #4608), and 1 half-dead black cherry (#4609) will need to be removed.
All trees targeted for removal are marked with pink tape in the field. View Tree Removal Plan
The watershed draining through this channel is approximately 1,318 acres. At the time of development of the Sauk Creek area the existing farm ditch was not required to be improved. As development has continued upstream, flows have continued to increase causing active and aggressive erosion in the channel. In the mid-1990’s, City Engineering approached the neighborhood with a project to stabilize the channel and the neighborhood rejected it. The channel has now degraded so badly that the project will need to be more aggressive to fix sections of channel that have 5’-6’ tall eroded banks.
Further, as a result of the continued erosion, there are many trees adjacent to the channel that have fallen across it forcing runoff water to create new channels in the greenway causing further erosion in a self-reinforcing cycle. One result of this is that the downstream Wexford pond is filling with sediment from the channel and now requires dredging. City Engineering has delayed dredging of that pond until the primary source of sediment to the pond is stabilized.
The channel width will not be known until the hydraulic and hydrologic modeling for the Madison Pheasant Branch Watershed Study is completed, which will be in advance of the next neighborhood meeting. Some things are known; in areas where there are 5’-6’ tall vertical banks as a result of erosion, the channel will need to expand to regrade those slopes. We also know the channel geometry will vary throughout the greenway based on existing topography.
Aug. 3, 2019: Work on Creek Crossing at Tree Lane
During the August 2018 floods, the concrete block that provided a ford for our sanitary sewer maintenance equipment to access the sewer was washed out. Our crews need to complete routine maintenance on the sanitary sewer to prevent sanitary backups from occurring; therefore our operations staff has been working to restore the ford crossing. The City decided that it is better to wait to improve the ford crossing with the greenway project (delayed until 2021), and complete a temporary fix in the interim. The cables between some of the concrete blocks broke while resetting the blocks, so the operations crews laid down breaker rock in the cracks to provide the stability needed for the large vactor truck to access the sanitary sewer.
It has been inaccurately stated that 2,200 trees will be removed. This is not an estimation that the City supports. As a design has not been proposed, there is not an estimated number of tree removals to provide at this time. A consultant completed a tree survey of the entire greenway for the channel project. The results of the survey highlighted habitat opportunities and documented the ecological degradation that has occurred in these woods due to a lack of invasive management. The youngest oaks in the forest are 80-100 years old. On the current trajectory, the mature oaks will slowly die off without being replaced. The City plans to create a sustainable, long-term restoration plan with help from experts and input from the community that will promote new oak growth and maintain this quality resource for future generations.
For more detailed information about the tree survey, and the ability to view quality tree locations and ratings, please view the Sauk Creek Greenway Restoration Tree Survey Story Map. Please note that the tree data is represented as dots on the map, you can zoom in to adjust the map scale by clicking "explore map" in the lower right corner.
Dedication of these Lands
These lands were dedicated to the City with several plats including a portion dedicated in 1976 near Tamarack Trails that was “Dedicated to the Public for Parkway Purposes.” The term “parkway” was used in the 1970’s for greenway dedications. The rest of the greenway was “Dedicated to the Public for Greenway and Park Purposes and Storm Water Detention” in the Sauk Creek Plat in 1985, and in the First Addition to Sauk Creek Plat in 1987.
Per the Definitions in the Official Map Ordinance 16.25 (3): the term “Parkway” for the purpose of this section shall include any right-of-way for vehicular or pedestrian traffic, or both, with full or partial control of access and usually located within a park or a ribbon of parklike development. Said parkway may include land area which is required for storm water drainage purposes where the drainage improvement is to include parklike treatment and where pedestrian or vehicular travel may be permitted. Per Ordinance Chapter 16.25(3) (above) and Chapter 16.23(2), both lands dedicated as Greenways and Parkways “may serve multiple purposes including, in addition to their principal use for storm drainage, vehicular and/or pedestrian traffic, sanitary sewers, water mains, storm sewers, storm water retention basins, park development and other related uses.”
The following outlines why a bike path is being considered with the greenway restoration project:
- The 1984 Park and Open Space Plan noted that Walnut Grove Park had a bikeway through it, and that “Park Master Plans should continue to plan for bicycle/pedestrian circulation adjacent to and within the park” but the Sauk Creek greenway was not yet shown on the map as City property.
- The 1991 and 1997 Park and Open Space Plans list Sauk Creek/Walnut Grove as an area for "potential new bike paths on parkland" and calls to “construct a bike path from Old Sauk Road to Tree Lane.”
- The 2000 adopted Bicycle Transportation Plan for the Madison Metropolitan Area and Dane County identifies Sauk Creek Greenway/Walnut Grove Park as a 3rd Priority project with a comment that “suitable on-road routes exist”
- The 2015 adopted Bicycle Transportation Plan for the Madison Metropolitan Area and Dane County includes a bike path in the Sauk Creek greenway system to provide North/South and East/West connections through the greenway.
The City is assessing community need in regards to the bike path. As the channel analysis progresses, the City will look at bike path need from a transportation perspective, as well as how the bike path would fit within the greenway design.
The City Parks Division is proposing an additional off-road trail network for mountain biking, snow shoeing, and skiing. In fall of 2020,underwent a citywide planning project to construct a network of natural surface, bike optimized trails throughout the city. This would serve as a “master plan” document only and doesn’t mean any of the individual segments would be constructed without a separate public engagement opportunity. Any natural surface trail would be separate from the greenway restoration work and potential paved path project.
Greenways have the potential to play a major role in connecting green spaces throughout the city. As part of this project, the Sauk Creek Greenway was identified as a potential site for such a trail. You can learn more about the Parks Division’s planning project at their MadBAT project website, or storymap.
Volunteers can make a big difference in the ecological health of the Sauk Creek Greenway. Additionally, preemptively removing invasive species can greatly curb the spread during reconstruction work. A few volunteer efforts that have made a big difference in the health of the greenway include garlic mustard pulling and buckthorn cutting.
Garlic mustard is an aggressive, herbaceous species that can take over entire woodlands and displace native wildflowers. In the spring of 2018, volunteers hand-pulled invasive garlic mustard in targeted locations allowing for a carpet of native wildflowers to emerge. Native species that benefited from garlic mustard removal include wild geranium, Solomon’s seal, Virginia bluebells, wood violets and wild ginger.
Winter brush cutting in 2018 and 2019 targets berry-producing buckthorn. Buckthorn can shade out native tree and woodland wildflower species, compact the soil and exacerbate erosion issues. The berries produced by buckthorn are attractive to wildlife, though they are indigestible to most birds and mammals and are soon dispelled in a new location. Cutting the berry-producing individuals removes potential seeds from the environment and opens up the canopy for diverse native species.
If you are interested in volunteering to help with restoration work in the Sauk Creek Greenway please contact Si Widstrand at firstname.lastname@example.org
The City will use information from the Madison Pheasant Branch Watershed Study to inform the design of this greenway. Therefore, this project is on hold until the watershed study reaches the solutions phase. The City anticipates this will occur during the first quarter of 2021.
There are a number of points of contact during this project where the public is encouraged to give feedback as part of public information meetings and public hearings. Dates and times are indicated below:
Public Information Meetings
A public information meeting was held March 13, 2018.
March 13, 2018 Public Information Meeting PowerPoint Presentation
Public Comments Received Through March 30, 2018
Separate, yet related public information meetings were held for the watershed this project is in.
A public information meeting for the Madison Pheasant Branch Watershed Study was held May 4, 2020 and June 18, 2020.
A third public meeting with proposed solutions needs to occur for the Madison Pheasant Branch Watershed study before additional meetings will occur for the Sauk Creek Greenway project. The Watershed Study solutions help to inform the design of the Sauk Creek Greenway channel.
City Meetings, Process
Board of Public Works: New information will be posted soon.
Common Council: New information will be posted soon.
The Ecological Summary, authored by Tree Health Management after completing the tree survey, can be found here: Sauk Creek Ecological Summary
Each tree greater than 3” in diameter at breast height was surveyed and given a condition rating. This occurred from November-December of 2017. The collected Tree Data in Excel spreadsheet format can be found here: Tree Data