- City of Madison
- Mayor's Office
- Blog
- The F-35 Final Environmental Impact Statement, Additional Information and Timeline
The F-35 Final Environmental Impact Statement, Additional Information and Timeline
Posted on Thursday, Feb. 27, 2020 at 10:50 am
As most people in Madison know by now, the U.S. Air Force (USAF) is transitioning its fleet to the F-35 fighter jet and is assessing five locations across the country. The selection of locations is a federal decision, not a City decision, which will be made by the Secretary of the Air Force. One step in that decision-making process is the development of an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) under the National Environmental Policy Act to assess the possible locations, and which will presumably inform the Air Force’s decision.
In November 2019, the City filed 22 pages of comments to the federal record on the draft EIS, asking questions and picking apart their analysis, which you can access here.
The final federal EIS for the F-35 is now available. It is an assessment of impacts on people and the environment at five locations. It encompasses some 931 pages, plus appendices, correspondence and supporting documents. I encourage you to review this document, which can be accessed here.
The abstract of the EIS states that “the USAF has identified 115 FW Madison, Wisconsin, as the preferred alternative for the 5th operational beddown, and the 185th Montgomery, Alabama as the preferred alternative for the 6th operational beddown.” However, this decision is not yet final.
The City demanded, and the final EIS provided, more information about “peak” noise levels. The document includes more information on this topic, including comparative sound levels for the F-16 and the F-35 at take-off and landing. You can see these peak noise levels in the chart below, and an explanation on pgs. B9-B11 of Appendix B.
The chart below indicates that the maximum loudness (Lmax) of the F-35 is five decibels more than the F-16. Three decibels is generally the threshold where people can perceive a difference in sound level (Appendix B, pg. B3), so while the Air Force anticipates some increase in loudness, it would not be four times as loud as some people fear. With regard to other questions we asked, they were responded to, but not all our questions were actually answered. As a result, we asked the state Department of Military Affairs (DMA) to provide further information and also provide responses to more recent questions and concerns we have heard from residents. DMA sent us a 17-page letter in reply. I encourage you to read this letter which is attached below.
Department of Military Affairs Letter
The DMA letter provides a few additional pieces of information, including:
The EIS projects more flights as the F-16s are retired and the F-35s arrive, but once the transition is complete, “the number of operations by F-35s at Truax will likely be similar to the number of operations by current day F-16s… The unit is not receiving more airplanes than currently assigned…generating 27% more flights without commensurate resources would be difficult,” (pg. 15).
The use of afterburner at Truax has troubled residents living near the air field. The Air National Guard F-16s use afterburner approximately 60% of the time on takeoff. The F-35 is a more powerful plane, so the EIS anticipates the use of afterburner only 5% of the time. In the meantime, ten F-35s have landed in Burlington, Vermont. The DMA notes that “In the time that the 158 FW in Burlington VT has operated the F-35s, since September 2019, their pilots have not had to use afterburner on any of their takeoffs,” (pg. 14).
On the issue of PFAS, the letter contains further updates. The letter states “[t]wo work plans have been submitted to the WI DNR to address DCRA storm water contamination and two Fire Training Areas that have been previously utilized by area fire departments.” In addition, “the Air National Guard has agreed to prepare a Material Management Plan for approval by the Wisconsin DNR,” (pg. 16). The MMP will outline how contaminated soil and water shall be safely handled and disposed of during construction activities. As part of this plan, Wisconsin law “requires the responsible party to establish site-specific cleanup standards in the absence of promulgated numeric standards,” the DNR wrote in a letter it filed to the draft EIS. The DNR has the ability to require tougher standards.
There is lots of additional information in the final EIS and in this letter from DMA. I encourage people to read these documents for themselves.
This final EIS will be published in the Federal Register on Feb. 28. Then, after a 30-day review period, a final decision will be made by the Secretary of the Air Force. In the meantime, Madison residents can direct correspondence to:
Ms. Barbara M. Barrett
Secretary of the Air Force
U.S. Department of the Air Force
1160 Airforce Pentagon
Washington, D.C. 20515
If Madison is chosen for the F-35, construction of new buildings would likely begin in 2020. Legally, “buildings built on federal property are exempt from state and local building codes,” as this General Services Document explains. Once again, the federal government has taken away our local control. Nonetheless, the City will do our best to uphold our standards and recommend best practices for construction and development if the project moves forward.
The National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) was created in the 1970s to require the federal government to consider the impact of its actions on people and the planet. This is the first time I have watched the federal government’s NEPA process up close, and I have to say I am unimpressed. What is the point of assessing environmental impacts if those impacts are found to be severe and then they go ignored? The final report indicates that there are lesser environmental impacts at three alternative sites. I recognize that a decision will be made by the USAF whether or not the City of Madison has any opinion on this matter, but I urge the Secretary of the Air Force to be true to the purpose and intent of the NEPA law.
Subscribe to Mayor Satya's Blog Updates
Archive
- Many Resources Available for Residents Seeking Financial Assistance Due to COVID-19 Hardship
- Mayor’s “Housing Forward” Sets Vision for Madison
- Midwest Mayors Write Secretary Buttigieg to Urge Expansion of Amtrak’s Hiawatha Line
- Celebrate National Library Week
- Celebrating National Community Development Week
- A (Pandemic) Year in the Life of Olbrich Gardens
- Get Green with the City this Spring
- #TeamCity Awards
- The American Rescue Plan Act is an economic lifeline and a bridge to our future
- Be Informed: Check Out Advisory Referendum Questions on the April 6 Ballot
- Governor Evers Proposes Long-Needed Action on Climate Change
- A Big Step Forward for Madison's Homeless Services
- Metro Should Deliver Front Door Transit Service
- Celebrating International Women's Day
- Progress Underway on Creation of Alternative Emergency Responders
- March 1: A Day of Remembrance and Recovery
- Supporting the Federal Equality Act
- Health Insurance Resources Available to Madisonians
- Supporting Small Business
- Emergency Rental Assistance: Local and Federal
- New Administration Takes Action on Immigration
- Black History Month Resources & Events from Madison Public Library
- Black History Month
- Madison Applauds President Biden’s Announcement that All Federal Fleets Will Be 100% Electric
- Supporting Our Unsheltered Neighbors
- Recognizing February 2021 as Black History Month in the City of Madison.
- Honoring Madison’s Health Care Heroes Battling COVID-19
- Reckoning with the Past, Writing the Future – Thoughts on Black History Month
- Mayoral Proclamation for Madison Native Karlin Younger
- Madison Featured as a Climate-Change Haven
- Madison Joins National Gun Violence Survivors Week Movement and Pledge
- Fifty Years and Counting
- Madison Kicks off 2021 with #Teamcity Awards Focused on Teamwork
- An Open Letter to Our New President and Vice President
- Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Day Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- Ya Estan Disponibles Los Fondos Para La Siguiente Ronda Del Programa De Proteccion De Pago (PPP)
- Next Round of Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Funding Available
- Growing our Housing Options in Madison with Cooperatives
- Honoring Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
- City Buildings and Fleet Named Dane County Climate Champions
- Madison Parks Keep You Active Outdoors this Winter
- A Message from the Streets Division-This Winter will be Different
- City Program to Support Small Businesses Underway
- Team City Awards
- Supporting Local Business and Each Other
- Safer to Report Harassment Under our New Policy
- Madison to Receive up to $500,000 to Support Guaranteed Income Pilot
- Madison Receives Highest Possible Score in Human Rights Campaign Annual Report
- Centering Racial Equity and Social Justice
- Displacement of Elderly Residents
- An Open Letter In Support of Meaningful Conversation and Action to Address Systemic Racism in Government and all American Institutions
- Eight Can’t Wait
- Addressing Racial Bias Within City Government
- Building an Inclusive Workplace
- Budget Spotlight: Housing and Community Services
- Madison ACRE Participants
- Shared Streets, Let’s Plan for Next Year
- The Federal Government Must Mitigate the Impacts of any F-35 Deployment
- Millions Available to Support Community-Based Organizations That Provide Affordable Housing
- Budget Spotlight: Equitable Economic Development Programs
- Federal Support for Alternative Crisis Response Teams
- Mayoral Proclamation: Election Hero Day
- Madison Clerk’s Office Honored for Safe, Secure Elections in the Midst of a Pandemic
- Madison Wins Salute To Local Government Awards -Effective Response to COVID-19 Challenge
- Five Mayors, One Challenge
- Asking Everyone to Do Their Part
- New Leaf & Yard Waste Pickup Schedule
- Vote Early Day is Saturday, October 24th
- In-Person Absentee Voting Underway
- Obama Highlights Madison Civilian Oversight Board
- The City's Financial Resources Hotline has been Launched
- Tough Choices on the Budget
- Millions of Dollars to Support Affordable Housing in Madison
- 2021 Executive Operating Budget Message
- Reimagining Public Safety - Progress and Budget Priorities
- Cast your ballot today!
- Pandemic Assistance for our Immigrant Residents-with clarifying information
- Local Municipalities Need Federal Pandemic Relief
- Seeking Support for Equitable Community Access to Elections
- Request to Public Service Commission to Extend Utility Shut-Off Moratorium
- The Need for Federal Pandemic Relief
- City's Streatery Program Growing Fast
- Mask Up Madison
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway and City Leaders Announce Agreement to End School Resource Officer Contract
- Juneteenth-A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- Dream Up and Dream Big-Dream Up Programs Advance
- Statement of Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway
- Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway and Common Council Members Write to Sheriff Mahoney
- Now Is Time For Change
- Join me in Supporting President Obama’s Call to Action on Police Reform
- Madison Mayor Tells Trump Not to Deploy the Military Against Protestors - Supports Rep. Pocan’s Bill to Require Congressional Authorization
- Statement of Mayor Rhodes-Conway Commemorating Breonna Taylor
- Statement of Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- Pride Survives
- "Streatery" Restaurant Recovery Program- A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- Phase One Reopening Begins Today in Madison
- Wear your Cloth Facial Coverings this Memorial Day Weekend!
- A Message from the Mayor About the Heroes Act in Congress
- City of Madison Invests in the Madison Black Chamber of Commerce and the Latino Chamber of Commerce to Help Businesses During the COVID-19 Crisis
- Public Health Madison and Dane County Announces Preparation Phase to Open Up Businesses in Dane County
- Data and Science Will Guide Our Decision Making
- Meet Justin Stuehrenberg- Metro Transit’s New General Manager
- Community Testing Site Now Available at Alliant Energy Center
- Your 2020 Census form – An Easy and Safe Way to Help our Community
- Friday Good News Updates
- An Update on our Community and COVID-19.
- Homegrown Harvests During the Badger Bounce Back
- Contact Tracing’s Role in Re-Opening Wisconsin
- A Friday Update of Some Good News and Opportunities from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- COVID-19 Testing: Why It Matters to Re-Opening the Economy, What it Takes, and Where Things Stand
- How Dangerous Is This Virus? How COVID-19 Attacks the Body
- Learning from the Past
- A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway Regarding Mental Health Care and COVID-19
- Some Opportunities During this Pandemic
- COVID-19 Update from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- Earth Day in the Time of COVID-19
- Badger Bounce Back - a Path to a Safer Recovery
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Statement in Support of First Responders during the COVID-19 Pandemic
- Some good news from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- COVID-19 Update from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- COVID-19 and Some Essential City Services
- Homeless Services – Response to COVID-19 Pandemic-A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Statement Regarding Community Gardens and COVID-19
- City of Madison Looking for COVID-19 Cloth Face Covering Donations
- Let’s Double Down on Physical Distancing and Social Solidarity
- Thank you for Supporting Our Elections! A Message from Mayor Rhodes- Conway
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway Update on COVID-19
- Tus Tswv Zos Rhodes-Conway Daim Ntawv Qhia Txog Tsis Txhob Xaiv Ntsej Xaiv Muag Hauv Lus Zej Zog
- Reaching Out and Helping Others
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Rejecting Racism in Our Community
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Transportation in Regards to COVID-19
- Wisconsin is the Only State in the Nation Moving Forward with an Election at this Stage of the Pandemic
- COVID-19 Update from Mayor Satya
- Complete the Census and Encourage Others to Join You!
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Statement Regarding COVID-19 and Protecting the Homeless
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on How to Slow the Spread of COVID-19
- City of Madison Actions on Coronavirus: Updated March 24
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Message Today at the Press Conference with the County Executive and Public Health Director
- Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Food with Regards to COVID-19
- Statement of Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway on Voting with Regard to COVID-19
- Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Local Business with Regards to COVID-19
- Taking Care of Children
- Mayor Rhodes-Conway Statement on City of Madison Actions on Coronavirus
- Our best defense is our collective action
Category
Uncategorized
-
The American Rescue Plan Act is an economic lifeline and a bridge to our future
-
Be Informed: Check Out Advisory Referendum Questions on the April 6 Ballot
-
Progress Underway on Creation of Alternative Emergency Responders
-
Madison Clerk’s Office Honored for Safe, Secure Elections in the Midst of a Pandemic
-
"Streatery" Restaurant Recovery Program- A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
-
Meet Justin Stuehrenberg- Metro Transit’s New General Manager
-
Community Testing Site Now Available at Alliant Energy Center
-
Your 2020 Census form – An Easy and Safe Way to Help our Community
-
A Friday Update of Some Good News and Opportunities from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
-
COVID-19 Testing: Why It Matters to Re-Opening the Economy, What it Takes, and Where Things Stand
-
A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway Regarding Mental Health Care and COVID-19
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Statement in Support of First Responders during the COVID-19 Pandemic
-
Homeless Services – Response to COVID-19 Pandemic-A Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
-
City of Madison Looking for COVID-19 Cloth Face Covering Donations
-
Let’s Double Down on Physical Distancing and Social Solidarity
-
Thank you for Supporting Our Elections! A Message from Mayor Rhodes- Conway
-
Tus Tswv Zos Rhodes-Conway Daim Ntawv Qhia Txog Tsis Txhob Xaiv Ntsej Xaiv Muag Hauv Lus Zej Zog
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Rejecting Racism in Our Community
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Statement Regarding COVID-19 and Protecting the Homeless
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on How to Slow the Spread of COVID-19
-
Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Food with Regards to COVID-19
-
Statement of Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway on Voting with Regard to COVID-19
-
Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway’s Statement on Local Business with Regards to COVID-19
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway Statement on City of Madison Actions on Coronavirus
-
The F-35 Final Environmental Impact Statement, Additional Information and Timeline
-
Statement by Mayor Rhodes-Conway on the Passing of Detective Nicholas Ryan
-
Comments Regarding F-35 Draft Environmental Impact Statement FR #2018-02468
-
City Staff Memo & Maps on F-35 Environmental Impact Statement
Affordable Housing
-
Many Resources Available for Residents Seeking Financial Assistance Due to COVID-19 Hardship
-
Madison Kicks off 2021 with #Teamcity Awards Focused on Teamwork
-
Madison to Receive up to $500,000 to Support Guaranteed Income Pilot
-
Millions Available to Support Community-Based Organizations That Provide Affordable Housing
-
Millions of Dollars to Support Affordable Housing in Madison
-
Urban League and City of Madison Announce Wealth-Building Partnership
Equity
-
Black History Month Resources & Events from Madison Public Library
-
Recognizing February 2021 as Black History Month in the City of Madison.
-
Reckoning with the Past, Writing the Future – Thoughts on Black History Month
-
Madison Joins National Gun Violence Survivors Week Movement and Pledge
-
Madison Kicks off 2021 with #Teamcity Awards Focused on Teamwork
-
Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Day Message from Mayor Rhodes-Conway
-
Ya Estan Disponibles Los Fondos Para La Siguiente Ronda Del Programa De Proteccion De Pago (PPP)
-
Next Round of Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Funding Available
-
A Message from the Streets Division-This Winter will be Different
-
Madison to Receive up to $500,000 to Support Guaranteed Income Pilot
-
Madison Receives Highest Possible Score in Human Rights Campaign Annual Report
-
The Federal Government Must Mitigate the Impacts of any F-35 Deployment
-
Madison Wins Salute To Local Government Awards -Effective Response to COVID-19 Challenge
-
Update on City Work Related to Criminal Justice Reform, Crime Prevention, and Racial Disparities
-
Urban League and City of Madison Announce Wealth-Building Partnership
-
Pandemic Assistance for our Immigrant Residents-with clarifying information
-
Request to Public Service Commission to Extend Utility Shut-Off Moratorium
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway and City Leaders Announce Agreement to End School Resource Officer Contract
-
Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway and Common Council Members Write to Sheriff Mahoney
-
Join me in Supporting President Obama’s Call to Action on Police Reform
-
Statement of Mayor Rhodes-Conway Commemorating Breonna Taylor
-
Welcome and Congratulations to the 62nd Class of Madison Police Department Recruits
Sustainability
-
Governor Evers Proposes Long-Needed Action on Climate Change
-
Madison Applauds President Biden’s Announcement that All Federal Fleets Will Be 100% Electric
-
Madison Kicks off 2021 with #Teamcity Awards Focused on Teamwork
-
City Buildings and Fleet Named Dane County Climate Champions
-
Mayor Rhodes-Conway's Statement Regarding Community Gardens and COVID-19
-
Not My Kind of Tea: Keeping Leaf Tea from Entering Our Lakes
Tags
- #TeamCity
- 2021 Operating Budget
- 8 Can't Wait
- AASPIRE
- absentee voting
- ACRE Program
- Addressing Racial Bias
- Affordable Housing
- Apprenticeship
- Assisted living
- ballot drop box
- Black History Month
- BRT
- Business
- CAHOOTS
- CBS Sunday Morning
- Census
- Child Care
- Children
- City Fleet
- City services
- Civilian Oversight Board
- Climate Champions
- Climate Change
- collaboration
- Community
- Community Development Week
- community investment
- Community Services
- contact tracing
- Coronavirus
- COVID
- COVID-19
- COVID-19 Relief
- Crisis Response Team
- Del Programa De Proteccion De Pago
- Department of Civil Rights
- Dream Up Program
- Early Voting Day
- Earth Day
- Earth Day Challenge
- Election Hero Day
- elections
- Electric Vehicles
- Employment and Training
- engineering
- environment
- Equity
- Equity Coordinator
- F-35
- F35 Noise Mitigation
- fair elections
- Federal Equity Act (H.R. 5)
- federal relief
- Financial Resources Hotline
- food
- Forward Dane
- gardening
- gardens
- Governor's Action on Climate Change
- Gun Violence Survivors Week
- Health
- health care heroes
- Health Insurance Resources
- Health/Wellness
- homeless
- homelessness
- Honorary #TeamCity
- Honoring Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
- housing
- Housing Co-ops
- Housing Forward
- immigration
- Inclusive workplace
- Infrastructure
- Internship
- Juneteenth
- leaf collection
- Length of Service
- Library
- Look Forward
- Madison Parks
- Madison Poilce
- Madison Police Department
- masks
- Mayors for Guaranteed Income
- Mayors Voting Challenge
- Mental Health
- Metro Transit
- MetroForward
- Muncipal Equality Index
- neighborhoods
- Olbrich Gardens
- Pandemic Assistance
- parks
- Paycheck Protection Program
- Policing
- polling locations
- President Biden
- Pride Month
- Prohibited Harassment and Discrmination Policy
- Public Safety
- Public Service Commission
- rail
- Reimagining Public Safety
- Rental assistance
- Safer at Home
- Safety
- SBER
- Shared streets
- Small Business Equity and Recovery
- Small Business Equity and Recovery Program
- social distance
- Spring Clean Up
- Statewide Award for Janel Heinrich
- Streatery
- Streets
- Support Local First
- Sustainability
- Systemic Racism
- Team City Award Winners
- TeamCity
- Testing
- train
- transportation
- Truax
- Vice President Harris
- Vote
- Voter Registration Day
- voting
- Winter snow removal
- Youth