CONTACT US || ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ||  HOUSING || NEIGHBORHOODS || ZONING


CITY OF MADISON:

Standards for Review of Development Proposals

 

The following Standards are used by the Plan Commission
to review development proposals.

 

Excerpts From The Following Sections of Madison General Ordinances: 

 

Jump to:

 

CONDITIONAL USES

The Zoning Code Sec. 28.12(11) includes the following provisions regarding conditional uses:

(a)     Statement of Purpose. The development and execution of this ordinance is based upon the division of the City into districts, within which districts the use of land and buildings, and bulk and location of buildings and structures in relation to the land, are mutually compatible and substantially uniform. However, there are certain uses which, because of their unique characteristics, cannot be properly classified as unrestricted permitted uses in any particular district or districts, without consideration, in each case, of the impact of those uses upon neighboring land or public facilities, and of the public need for the particular use at a particular location. Such uses, nevertheless, may be necessary or desirable to be allowed in a particular district provided that due consideration is given to location, development, and operation of such uses. Such uses are classified as conditional uses and fall into two (2) categories:

  1. Uses publicly operated or traditionally affected with a public interest.

  2. Uses entirely private in character, but of such an unusual nature that their operation may give rise to unique problems with respect to their impact upon neighboring property or public facilities.

The following provisions are thus established to regulate these conditional uses which require special consideration.

(g)     Standards. No application for a conditional use shall be granted by the City Plan Commission unless such Commission shall find all of the following conditions are present:

  1. That the establishment, maintenance or operation of the conditional use will not be detrimental to or endanger the public health, safety, or general welfare.

  2. That the City be able to provide municipal services to the property where the conditional use is proposed, given due consideration of the cost of providing such services.

  3. That the uses, values and enjoyment of other property in the neighborhood for purposes already established shall be in no foreseeable manner substantially impaired or diminished by the establishment, maintenance or operation of the conditional use.

  4. That the establishment of the conditional use will not impede the normal and orderly development and improvement of the surrounding property for uses permitted in the district.

  5. That adequate utilities, access roads, drainage, parking supply, internal circulation improvements, including but not limited to vehicular, pedestrian, bicycle, public transit, and other necessary site improvements have been or are being provided.

  6. That measures, which may include transportation demand management (TDM) and participation in a transportation management association, have been or will be taken to provide adequate ingress and egress, including all off-site improvements, so designed as to minimize traffic congestion and to ensure public safety and adequate traffic flow, both on-site and on the public streets.

  7. That the conditional use shall conform to all applicable regulations of the district in which it is located.

  8. That when applying the above standards to an application by a community living arrangement the City Plan Commission shall:

  1. Bear in mind the City's general intent to accommodate community living arrangements.

  2. Exercise care to avoid an over-concentration of community living arrangements which could create an institutional setting and seriously strain the existing social structure of a community. Considerations relevant for this determination are:

  1. The distance separating the proposed community living arrangement from other such facilities.

  2. The capacity of the community living arrangement and the percent the facility will increase the population of the community.

  3. The total capacity of all the community living arrangements in the community.

  4. The impact on the community of other community living arrangements.

  5. The success or failure of integration into communities of other community living arrangements operated by the individual or group seeking the conditional use permit.

  6. The ability of the community to meet the special needs, if any, of the applicant facility.

  1. That when applying the above standards to any new construction of a building or an addition to an existing building, the City Plan Commission:

  1. Shall bear in mind the statement of purpose for the zoning district, such that the proposed building or addition at its location does not defeat the purposes and objective of the zoning district; and

  2. May require the applicant to submit plans to the Urban Design Commission for comments and recommendations; and

  3. May consider the use of the proposed building as it relates to the City's Land Use Plan.

When a Conditional Use application is denied, the Plan Commission shall furnish the applicant in writing those standards that are not met and enumerate reasons the Commission has used in determining that each standard was not met.

 

Back to Top

 

DEMOLITION OR REMOVAL

The Zoning Code Sec. 28.04(22) includes the following provisions regarding Approval of Razing, Demolition, Removal, or Wrecking of buildings:

(a)     Statement of Purpose. It is hereby declared a matter of public policy that the good maintenance and rehabilitation of existing buildings, the preservation of safe and sanitary housing available at reasonable prices, and the careful consideration and planning of changes in the urban landscape are a public necessity and are required in the interest of the health, prosperity, safety, and welfare of the people. The purpose of this section is to:

1.      Foster and encourage the preservation of existing buildings which are structurally sound, economically productive, and suitable for rehabilitation or repair.

2.      Encourage voluntary compliance with building and minimum housing codes.

3.      Aid in the preservation of residential neighborhoods.

4.      Require the Plan Commission to evaluate proposed alternative uses of property before existing buildings are destroyed or moved.

5.      Allow the property owner to have a decision on approval or disapproval of the proposed use of the property before he or she takes the irrevocable step of demolishing or moving his or her existing building or buildings.

6.      Foster and encourage adherence to the intent and purpose of the Zoning Code, as expressed in that code's general intent and purpose, Section 28.02 of the Madison General Ordinances, and as expressed in the individual Statements of Purpose for each of the zoning districts established by the code.

(c)     Standards. Applications for wrecking permits shall not be approved, except as provided in Section 28.04(22)(d) of the Madison General Ordinances, unless the following conditions are met:

1.      The Zoning Administrator issues a zoning certificate for the proposed use of the property. For the purpose of this subdivision, a zoning certificate shall mean a certification in writing that the proposed use of the property would be in compliance with the provisions of the Zoning Code, Chapter 28, Madison General Ordinances.

a.    If the Zoning Administrator finds that the proposed use of the property is not in compliance with the provisions of the Zoning Code, the applicant for a wrecking permit may follow the procedures provided by the Zoning Code to apply for an amendment, pursuant to Section 28.12(10) of the Madison General Ordinances or for a conditional use permit pursuant to Section 28.12(11) for the proposed use. All of the provisions of Sections 28.12(10) and 28.12(11) shall apply to said applications, except that the time limit for commencement of the conditional use, pursuant to Section 28.12(10)(b)3., shall be eighteen (18) months instead of twelve (12) months.

b.   If after the procedures provided in Paragraph 1 are followed, the proposed use of the property would be in compliance with the provisions of the Zoning Code, the Zoning Administrator shall grant a zoning certificate for the proposed use, pursuant to Madison General Ordinance Section 28.12(5)(a).

2.      The Plan Commission finds that both the requested demolition and the proposed use are compatible with the purpose of this Section and the intent and purpose expressed in the Zoning Code for the zoning district in which the property is located. When making this finding, the Commission shall consider and may give decisive weight to any relevant facts including but not limited to the effects the proposed demolition and proposed use of the subject property would have on the normal and orderly development and improvement of surrounding properties, and the availability of affordable housing after giving due consideration to the adopted master plan.

3.      In the case of landmarks or improvements located in an Historic District, consideration and approval of wrecking permits by the Plan Commission shall be contingent upon the prior issuance of a certificate of appropriateness therefore by the Landmarks Commission pursuant to Section 33.01(5)(c) of the Madison General Ordinances.

 

Back to Top

 

PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT DISTRICT (PUD)

The Zoning Code Sec. 28.07(6) includes the following provisions regarding Planned Unit Developments:

(a)     Statement of Purpose. The Planned Unit Development District is established to provide a voluntary regulatory framework designed to encourage and promote improved environmental and aesthetic design in the City of Madison by allowing for greater freedom, imagination and flexibility in the development of land while insuring substantial compliance to the basic intent of the zoning code and the general plan for community development. To this intent, it allows diversification and variation in the bulk and relationship of uses, structures and spaces in developments conceived as comprehensive and cohesive unified plans and projects. It is further intended to encourage developments consistent with coordinated area site planning.

(f)     Criteria for Approval. As a basis for determining the acceptability of a Planned Unit Development District application, the following criteria shall be applied with specific consideration as to whether or not it is consistent with the spirit and intent of this ordinance and has the potential for producing significant community benefits in terms of environmental and aesthetic design. For Planned Unit Development Districts with Residential Components in Downtown Design Zones, the Design Criteria adopted by the Common Council shall be used as guidelines for determining whether the following criteria are met.

1.      Character and Intensity of Land Use. In a Planned Unit Development District, the uses and their intensity, appearance and arrangement shall be of a visual and operational character which:

a.    Are compatible with the physical nature of the site or area.

b.   Would produce an attractive environment of sustained aesthetic desirability, economic stability and functional practicality compatible with the general development plan.

c.   Would not adversely affect the anticipated provision for school or other municipal service unless jointly resolved.

d.   Would not create a traffic or parking demand incompatible with the existing or proposed facilities to serve it unless jointly resolved. A traffic demand management plan and participation in a transportation management association may provide a basis for addressing traffic and parking demand concerns.

2.      Economic Impact. Planned Unit Development District shall not adversely affect the economic prosperity of the City or the area of the City where the Planned Unit Development is proposed including the cost of providing municipal services.

3.      Preservation and Maintenance of Open Space. In a Planned Unit Development District, adequate provision for the improvement and continuing preservation and maintenance of attractive open space shall be made.

4.      Implementation Schedule. A Planned Unit Development District shall include suitable assurances that each phase could be completed in a manner which would not result in an adverse effect upon the community as a result of termination at that point.

 

Back to Top

 

WATERFRONT DEVELOPMENT

In addition to the conditional use standards, Zoning Code Sec. 28.04(19) includes the following provisions applicable to waterfront development:

(a)     Statement of Purpose. This subsection is established to further the maintenance of safe and healthful conditions, prevent and control water pollution, protect spawning grounds, fish and aquatic life by controlling building sites, the placement of structures and land users and reserving shore cover and natural beauty for all waterfront and shoreland development.

(b)     General Regulations. The following regulations shall apply to all new development except a Civic Auditorium Complex. No building permit shall be issued for any new development of a waterfront or shoreland zoning lot without first obtaining a conditional use permit therefore. For purposes of this section, new development shall be a new principal building, an addition in excess of five hundred (500) square feet of floor area to an existing principal building, or an accessory building. The conditional use permit shall be issued pursuant to the procedure set forth in Section 28.12(10) of this ordinance. In addition to the review standards set forth in Subdivision (g) therein all waterfront development shall be subject to the following standards.

1.      For purposes of this section, the existing development pattern shall mean the average setback of the five (5) developed zoning lots to each side of the proposed development lot. For all zoning lots, the principal building setback shall be not less than the existing development pattern.

2.      Upon the filing of an application for a conditional use permit, the development plan shall show a complete inventory of shoreline vegetation in any area proposed for building, filling, grading, or excavating. In addition, the development plan shall indicate those trees and shrubbery which will be removed as a result of the proposed development. The cutting of trees and shrubbery shall be limited in the strip thirty-five (35) feet inland from the normal waterline. On any zoning lot not more than thirty percent (30%) of the frontage shall be cleared of trees and shrubbery. Within the waterfront setback requirements tree and shrub cutting shall be limited by consideration of the effect on water quality, protection and scenic beauty, erosion control and reduction of the effluents and nutrients from the shoreland.

3.      Any building development for habitation shall be served with public sanitary sewer.

4.      Filling, grading, and excavation of the zoning lot may be permitted only where protection against erosion, sedimentation, and impairment of fish and aquatic life has been assured.

5.      Where the City's adopted Master Plan includes a pedestrian walkway or bikepath along the shoreline, the proposed development shall not interfere with its proposed location.

6.      Construction of marine retaining walls or bulkhead may be permitted providing such construction does not protrude beyond the established shoreline of the adjacent properties. Said retaining walls and bulkheads will be permitted only for the purpose of preventing shoreline recession. The filling and grading of the shoreline shall occur only in the construction of such retaining walls or bulkheads.

7.      In addition to complying with the above standards, boathouses shall not be constructed for human habitation.

 

October 2003

 

Back to Top