First Settlement

History

This neighborhood is southeast of the Capitol Square and is the location of the first Euro-American settlement for what became Madison.

In 1837, Eben and Roaslie Peck built a boarding house on what is now S. Blair St. for the builders of the first state capitol. Their log cabin was the first Euro-American house in Madison. The neighborhood grew and contained a mix of housing types.

Post-World War II, the State redeveloped two blocks in the neighborhood for new government office buildings, next to a block that the City has redeveloped as a surface parking lot.

City plans in the 1960s-1970s marked the entire residential neighborhood for redevelopment to new uses. In the late 1970s, Madisonians began to move back into what was a blighted neighborhood to fix up the houses. The reinvestment grew the neighborhood again and residents organized to save this early residential part of Madison.

Following the recommendations of the 1995 First Settlement Neighborhood Master Plan, the Common Council named this our 5th historic district in 2002.

Map of First Settlement local historic district

Historic Designation

The First Settlement Historic District reflects the broad cultural, political, economic and social history of Madison, the state and the nation and in that elements within the district meet designation criteria, specifically that they are:

  • Identified with historic personages or with important local historical events.
  • Embody the distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type specimen, inherently valuable for a study of a period, style, method of construction or of local material or craftsmanship.

Architecture

First Settlement features mostly residential structures with a few religious and commercial buildings. This district represents working and professional class neighborhood of the last half of the 19th century and the early 20th century, with vernacular interpretations of popular architectural styles. The significant architectural styles found in the district include: 

  • Dutch Colonial Revival 
  • Gothic Revival 
  • Italianate 
  • Romanesque Revival 
  • Queen Anne

Historic Materials

  • Brick 
  • Wood clapboard (4" exposure) 
  • Wood shingles

Historic Resources

  • Landmarks 
  • Landmark sites 
  • Properties constructed during the period of significance, 1850-1930
Was this page helpful to you? * required