Statement from PCOB Chair Devon Snyder: The Future of Independent Civilian Oversight in Madison
The Common Council's decision to remove Independent Monitor Meeka Glass has created significant uncertainty about the future of Madison's civilian oversight system and the Office of the Independent Monitor. While reasonable people may disagree with that decision, I am deeply concerned that it occurred without a clearly communicated transition plan. That uncertainty affects not only the continuity of the office's operations, but also public confidence in the oversight process and the independence of civilian oversight itself.
Since the Council's action, my priority has been ensuring that the Office of the Independent Monitor remains operational, accessible, and responsive to the community. I have been working closely with Karen and communicating regularly regarding transition planning to ensure that residents continue to have a place to bring concerns and complaints and that the important work of oversight continues without unnecessary disruption.
My greatest concern is for the people who rely on this office. Community members who have come forward deserve assurance that their complaints will continue to be received and reviewed. They should not bear the consequences of leadership changes or political decisions. Maintaining continuity for ongoing investigations and casework remains one of my biggest concerns. Unfortunately, investigations will be paused until a permanent independent monitor is hired.
The Police Civilian Oversight Board will still continue the process of identifying and hiring a new Independent Monitor in accordance with city ordinances. As Chair, I will advocate for a transparent, fair, and independent process that follows the law and earns the trust of the community. The strength of civilian oversight depends not only on who serves as Monitor, but on the integrity of the process used to select that person.
While the Board has not taken a formal position on the Council's decision, I can speak for myself. I was disappointed by the removal of Meeka Glass and remain concerned about what it means for the future of independent oversight in Madison. Regardless of differing opinions about her performance, I believe our focus must now be on protecting the institution of civilian oversight and ensuring that its mission continues uninterrupted.
The Police Civilian Oversight Board was created to provide meaningful accountability, transparency, and independent oversight of policing in Madison. That mission has not changed. The community deserves a strong, credible, and independent oversight system that remains focused on fairness, accountability, and public trust.
As Chair, I will continue doing everything within my power to protect that system, support the continuation of the Office of the Independent Monitor's work, and ensure that the voices of community members continue to be heard. Madison's commitment to civilian oversight must be measured not during easy moments, but during challenging ones. I remain committed to that mission and to preserving public trust in the oversight process.
Devon Snyder
Police Civilian Oversight Board Chair