Police Accountability and Independent Community Oversight

District 13

Alder Tag Evers

Alder Evers’ Blog

August 31, 2020 12:25 PM

Hi Everyone,

(A tip of my hat to Alder Rummel for her post on this subject. Much of what follows I've borrowed from her excellent summary.)

The Final Report of the Alder Work Group to Develop Logistics & Operational Details for Madison Police Department Independent Civilian Oversight, the ordinances establishing the Office of the Independent Police Monitor and the Police Civilian Oversight Board, and amendments to the budget to allocate funds for the new monitor position, administrative and investigative support staff and funding for the oversight board will be voted on at Council Tuesday night.

Council members have received well over a hundred emails in the last week, the majority of residents support establishing the Office of the Independent Monitor and the Civilian Oversight Board. The Alder Work Group final report, ordinances, position description and budget authorizations were approved at Finance, Equal Opportunities Commission and the Public Safety Review Commission. But at last Friday's almost six hour Common Council Executive Committee (CCEC) meeting three of the four items failed on a 3-3 with the Council President choosing not the vote.

I am in support of the Alder Work Group report, the ordinance to create the Office of the Independent Monitor and Civilian Oversight Board, amendments to 2020 budget to move forward and the position description. If you want to provide comments, please email allalders@cityofmadison.com.

The proposed ordinance to establish an Office of the Independent Police Monitor and the Police Civilian Oversight Board represents a careful review of experiences from other communities in order to improve police accountability, develop a fair and impartial process for all stakeholders, and provide effective community control of the police. The ordinance proposes a hybrid model of an oversight board and monitor to review complaints and look at policies, procedures and patterns based on the recommendation of the Ad Hoc Committee. During the drafting of the ordinance, position description and final report, the Alder Work Group relied on the expertise of representatives from the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement (NACOLE) at https://www.nacole.org/. Brian Corr, Past President of NACOLE and Liana Perez, another NACOLE Board member attended the CCEC meeting and answered questions. They provided lots of information about how other cities have arranged and organized police oversight systems.

The following includes issues raised during the CCEC meeting:

The monitor and Civilian Oversight Board must be independent of the law enforcement departments they oversee and independent of elected officials. The Monitor would be recruited and appointed by a Board consisting of 11 members and 2 alternates. The Monitor, unlike most City of Madison department heads, will not report to the Mayor. In placing the Monitor under the supervision of the Board, the Alder Workgroup reviewed similar structures used in San Jose, Syracuse, and Eugene and is recommending this approach as the best method to hold the Monitor accountable to the community.
The Monitor and the Oversight Board may conduct independent investigations of all Police Department personnel, including the Police Chief as well as monitor MPD programs, activities, investigations, and use-of-force incidents. The Monitor may, to the extent permitted by law, issue subpoenas for the purpose of compelling testimony or receiving documents necessary to fulfill the duties of the Office of the Independent Monitor. The enabling legislation allows the Monitor to retain investigators to assist the Board. The results of those processes would be recommendations and not final determinations since the Police and Fire Commission has that authority by state statute. The Board is also charged with conducting community outreach and completing an annual public report to the Mayor and Council containing an assessment of the performance of the Monitor, the Board and MPD.
The Monitor shall have never been employed by the MPD, be an immediate family member of current or former MPD employees, or worked as a law enforcement officer within the State of Wisconsin in the ten years prior to appointment as Monitor.
The Ad Hoc Committee recommended, and the proposed ordinance requires, that the Civilian Oversight Board membership include a diversity of membership, including racial and ethnic backgrounds, age, socioeconomic status, gender, geographic residence in the City, work experience, and lived experience with homelessness, mental health, substance abuse and/or arrest or conviction record. The ordinance states that no Member shall have ever been employed by the MPD, be an immediate family member of current or former MPD employees, or worked as a law enforcement officer within the State of Wisconsin in the ten years prior to becoming a Member of the Board. The draft ordinance provides that at least one member be Black, Asian, Latinx, Native American, a member of the LGBTQ community, as well as that at least one member be affiliated with organizations in the field of mental health, youth advocacy, and AODA, and at least one member have an arrest or conviction record. The draft ordinance incorporates those membership requirements but the Alder Workgroup has separately recommended in its Final Report that the Board consist of at least 50% members who are Black.
In order to help foster diversity of the Civilian Oversight Board membership and effective participation in meetings, each board member will receive a $100 per month stipend, members of the board's executive committee shall receive an additional $25 per month in addition to the board member stipend; child care shall be provided during board meetings for board members that require that service; board members shall receive annual training; information technology hardware, software and training shall be provided to board members needing that service; and funding for attendance by elements of the board at national conferences.

Last week Mayor Rhodes-Conway issued a statement with a summary of changes underway Update on City Work Related to Criminal Justice Reform, Crime Prevention, and Racial Disparities

The police shooting of Kenosha resident Jacob Blake in front of his children is unacceptable. Council leadership issued a statement on shooting of Jacob Blake. The disparate treatment by police and right wing media of Jacob Blake who may have carried a knife and was shot in the back seven times by police and the 17 year old vigilante from Illinois who carried a weapon without a permit, crossed state lines twice, brandished his AR-15 like weapon in a crowd, violated curfew and allegedly shot at three and killed two people because he was supposedly defending property with a group of vigilantes is dizzying.

Police accountability is significantly enhanced by independent community oversight. We have a historic opportunity for systemic change. The time is now.

Take care and stay safe.

Tag

Tags: Independent Community Oversight, Jacob Blake, Kenosha, Police Brutality, Policing

Email to a friend

Labels

Uncategorized

Tags

1109 S. Park 1224 S. Park 2020 Census 2020 Referenda 5G Technology Accessory Dwelling Units Affordable Housing Affordable Housing Fund Affordable Housing; Police Chief Ahmaud Arbery Alder Pay Aldo Leopold Allen Arntsen Alleys American Plan Rescue Act Anisa Scott Annie Stewart Fountain Anthony Cooper Anti-Racism Arboretum ARPA Aurielle Smith Badger Football Bay Creek Bayview Bayview Foundation Bicycling Big Step Bikeways Biking Black Lives Matter Board of Parks Commissioners Board of Public Works Body Worn Cameras Brandi Grayson Brittingham Park BRT Brush Collection Budget Buildings Energy Savings Program Bus Rapid Transit C.A.R.E.S. CARES Program CDA Cedar Street City Budget Civilian Oversight Board Clean Lakes Alliance Clean Streets/Clean Lakes Clean Up Clear Sidewalks Climate Change Common Council Community Control Community Input Complete Green Streets Composting Computers Corporate Power COVID-19 Crime Curbside collection D13 Mask Brigade D13 Neighborhood Alliance D14 Alder Sheri Carter Dairy Drive Damond Boatwright Dark Sky Ordinance Defund The Police Development Development Digital Inclusion Diversity Dog Parks Dogs in Parks Dudgeon Monroe Dudgeon-Monroe Neighborhood Assn Earth Day Earth Week Ecology Economic crisis Edgewood High School Edgewood Stadium Effigy Mounds Elections Encampments Engineering Division Environment Environmental Justice Environmental Racism Eviction Prevention F-35s Finance Committee Financial Assistance Focused Interruption Coalition Food Access Food Deserts Food Drive Food Scraps Recycling Forest Hill Cemetery Forest Hills Cemetery Forward Dane Friend of Olin-Turville Friends of Lake Wingra Friends of Monona Bay Friends of Olin-Turville Gallery Night Gaylord Nelson Gentrification George Floyd Glen Golf Park Glenway Golf Course Glenway Golf Park Glenway Woods Good Neighbor Gathering Goodman Pool grassroots leadership Green Infrastructure Green New Deal Greenbush GreenPower Program Grocery Gap Gun violence Henry Vilas Zoo Ho Chunk Ho-Chunk Nation Homeless Services Hope Housing Housing Ordinances Immigrant Rights Independent Community Oversight Internships Jacob Blake Jazz In The Park John Muir John Nolen Drive Reconstruction Judge Everett Mitchell Juneteenth Kaleem Caire Kenosha Lake Monona Waterfront Lake Weeds Lake Wingra Lakeside Street Law Park Leaf Management Leaf Pick-up Light Pollution Listening Session Local Preemption Luna's Groceries Madison Bike Week Madison Fire Department Madison Forward Fund Madison Metro Madison Parks Madison Parks Foundation Madison Public Library Madison Water Utility MaskUpMadison Master Plan Maurer's Urban Market Mayor Satya McGrath E. Olin Project McGrath Project McGrath Property Group Men's Homeless Shelter Metro Transit Network Redesign MLK Day MMSD MMSD Monona Bay Monroe Street Monroe Street Festival Monroe Street Library Move Madison Forward Movin' Out MPD MPD Nature Neighborhood House Neighborhood Indicators Project New Day New Grocery Store Noise Pollution Office Hours Olin Ave Olin Park Oscar Mayer Special Area Plan Parking Restrictions Parks Passenger Rail Paul Wellstone Pedestrian Safety PFAS PFAS PFAS Phosphorous Pick N' Save Plan Commission Plan Commission Planning Framework Police & Fire Commission Police Brutality Policing Property Assessment Property Damage Protests Public Art Public Health Public Hearing Public safety Public Safety Review Commission Racial Disparities Racial Equity Racism Rain Gardens Recycling Recycling User Fee Redistricting Regent Street Reindahl Park Rental Assistance Reparations Resident Input Resource Recovery Charge Restorative Justice Road Salt Romnes Rule Enterprises Safe Streets Madison Salt Routes Sandbags Schools Schools Service Shared Streets Shared Use Paths Sidewalks Snow Emergency Zone Snow Update Social Distancing Social Distancing Solar South Madison South Madison Plan South Park Corridor Southwest Commuter Path Spring cleaning SROs SSM SSM Clinic State Rep. Shelia Stubbs State Street State Street riots State Street riots Stormwater Retention Streatery Street Closings Street Reconstruction Street Repair Streets Sustainability Sustainable Future TFOGS Tiny Homes Together Town of Madison Traffic Calming Traffic Impacts Traffic Safety Traffic Speed Transit Transit-Oriented Development Transportation Transportation Commission Transportation Demand Management Trash Collection Tree Canopy Tree Pruning Trees Triangle Truax Truman Olson Urban Design Commission Urban Forestry Task Force Urban Triage Vaccination Vaccine Availability Vaccines VFW Redevelopment Viewshed Vilas Vilas Park Vilas Park Drive Vilas Park Master Plan Violence Prevention Vision Zero Volunteer Opportunities Voter Registration Voting Walking Water Conservation Water Quality Waterfront Planning Watershed Studies West High White Militia Vigilantes White Supremacy Wingra Park Wingra Proper Watershed Study Wingra Triangle Wingra Triangle Winter Winter Parking Wonder Bar Yard Waste Zoning Zoning Ordinance

Common Council

District 13

Alder Tag Evers

Alder Tag Evers

Alder Evers’ Blog