Week of May 25, 2026

posted 

District Niners,

Last week the quarterly and annual reports from the MPD, the PCOB and the OIM were presented to the legislative body of the City of Madison.  Without delving into the “she said/he did/she did" incident between the PCOB Chair and the MPD chronology and specifics, my focus here addresses ethical concerns and a lack of awareness, judgment, personal biases, the need for recusal or whatever else you choose to call it on the part of the OIM.

Given the nature of the role of the PCOB (to hire and supervise the OIM,) and the role of the OIM (to monitor, assess police practices and procedures, facilitate community engagement, collect and analyze data, etc.), it is mind-boggling to try to understand and trust the decision made by the OIM absent objectivity, fairness and transparency, especially in this case when the principal player happens to be the Chair of the PCOB.  To ensure fairness, community trust, objectivity, etc., the OIM should have recused herself and not touched this case with a 50-foot pole.

Both parties, the PCOB chair and the OIM were asked a series of questions about the reports and questions related to ethical dilemmas following their reports.  Neither addressed nor had an awareness of the appearance of impropriety, justifications for conclusions drawn or short-term or long-term implications for citizens who could encounter a similar fate.  Fairness and impartiality were nowhere to be found by the PCOB chair or the OIM.  Was the fox guarding the hen house?   

Oversight demands Impartiality period!   What happened to integrity?  How much community or public trust did or will we lose?  What is the cost of perception?  Are there instances or a need for “external bodies" to investigate cases such as these?  There is a great need for written ethical standards.  We can and we must do better!

Updates and Notices

The City of Madison's administrative offices will be closed on Monday, May 25, 2026, for Memorial Day.

Boards, Commissions & Committee Meetings

Note: This is not a complete list of meetings for this upcoming week. All meetings and their details can be found at the Meeting Schedule page.

  • Joint Campus Area Committee: The Joint Campus Area Committee meeting will take place on Thursday, May 28, at 4:45 p.m. in virtual format. Agenda items include an update on the Regent Street reconstruction.

Meeting Details

Meeting Agenda

Register for Public Comment

Watch Online

If you would like more information about becoming a member of a City board, commission, or committee, please visit the page linked here.

Public Information Meetings (PIMs)

Announcements & News Releases

Please visit the City news webpage to find additional news and announcements and to subscribe to receive notification of news releases as they are posted.

Events

Additional upcoming events can also be found on the City events calendar.

Your well-being

Many years ago, I met Joe Mantegna (a famous Chicago actor) at a Cubs game at Wrigley field in Chicago after I fell and banged up my leg on a step.  I was remined of that scar by a kid a few days ago when she asked, “what happened to your leg?"  I then remembered a phrase uttered by Joe Mantegna (the actor) who said to me: “Scars remind us of where we have been, they don't have to dictate where we are going."  How prophetic! 

Until next time, take care.

Joann

Was this page helpful to you? * required
Portrait of Alder Joann Pritchett

Alder Joann Pritchett

District 9
Contact Alder Pritchett