Hurt, Harm, Accountability, And Telling The Truth
postedHi there,
I've read the false narratives being made publicly by the former Interim Independent Police Monitor, including the accusations directed at me and the way she is now portraying the work surrounding the Office of the Independent Police Monitor (OIPM) and the Police Civilian Oversight Board (PCOB).
Folks across our City deserve facts, not false narratives stemming from disagreements, hurt feelings or frustration.
We're actually investing in effective police oversight vs harming oversight with false narratives
My work has been about investing in effective independent police oversight. I sponsored $105,000 in budget amendments to support hiring an investigator, and working with the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement (NACOLE) to address structural issues and identify what is needed to strengthen the office through the 2027 budget process.
Those are actual actions to strengthen police oversight, not weaken it.
I recognize that being removed from a position can be difficult. It can be disappointing, frustrating, and even hurtful. I cannot speak to what the former IIM is feeling, and I am not trying to say that she is not entitled to disagree with the decision that the Common Council made.
But being hurt or angry about the end of an employment relationship does not give anyone a pass to make false accusations, misrepresent other people's actions, or turn a professional disagreement into a personal campaign against me and others they believe are responsible. It also doesn't give her a pass to continue sowing division among community members and using false narratives to appeal to folks' emotions.
And of course I have to address the timing of this latest report.
It is difficult to ignore that this report, filled with allegations about me and others, was released within 24 hours of Corey Ruiz's family expecting to receive an update from the District Attorney. His family deserves the community's attention, compassion, and space as they receive information about a case that has and will continue to deeply affect them.
Instead, the conversation has once again been pulled toward the former IIM, her grievances, and her version of events. I find that really messed up. There are moments when the needs of a family and the needs of a community should come before an individual's desire to make their own story the center of public attention.
There are real people and real families affected by these issues. They should not continually have to compete with personal disputes and public campaigns for attention.
The former IIM was entrusted with public accountability, yet repeatedly makes serious false allegations, misrepresents other people's actions, and encourages the public to see those people as enemies, and that harm does not stop with the individuals being targeted.
It creates distrust. It encourages people to believe that anyone who disagrees with her must be against Black people or against police accountability. It also turns this complicated conversation about the structure, performance, and future of the oversight office into a personal fight. And it is making it harder for people to have honest conversations about what needs to change and how we move forward.
That is harmful to this community.
It is especially harmful to Black folks across our City who have continued to advocate for meaningful police accountability for years and deserve an effective oversight system that works. We don't need more false narratives, personal attacks, and competing narratives. We actually DO deserve an office that is effective, credible, legitimate and accountable to the people it is supposed to serve.
Disagreeing with someone does not make me less committed to this community. And being a Black woman in public office does not mean I should be expected to remain silent when false claims are made and spread about me and others.
I have spent years serving Madison, especially serving Black people. People can disagree with my decisions and question my leadership if they'd like. But accountability has to work both ways. It cannot mean that one person gets to make seriously false allegations without being questioned and called out about the accuracy of those allegations or their own responsibility.
As usual, I will stay committed to the work of strengthening police civilian oversight in Madison. I also remain committed to telling the truth about my role in these decisions. This is also why I regularly encourage people to attend meetings, and read records so that people have the information and what someone said or didn't say for themselves.
Lastly, I've recently met with current PCOB chair Devon Snyder one-on-one, and in another meeting, joined by Alder Figueroa Cole, PCOB member Stephanie Rearick, and Council Chief of Staff Karen Kapusta-Pofahl. Chair Snyder was clear in that he understood why the former IIM was terminated now that he had more information. He shared how he's been getting more information now as the current Chair. Information that Chair Pearson was not sharing with the PCOB. He expressed his frustration about the lack of internal communications within the Board. He also shared his frustration that his words were taken out of context in a recent Madison365 article where I was called a token. It's my hope that Chair Snyder will be open with the general public about his thoughts as much as he was open in both meetings where he shared his frustrations and understandings. The community deserves transparency and an opportunity to hear directly from those involved not have these false narratives continue to take up space.
I also hope that former PCOB Chair Maia Pearson, and Alders Matthews and Glenn, are publicly truthful about comments they've made about the ineffectiveness of this office in conversations away from the public versus continuing to take part in shaping false narratives. Your participation in not actually addressing the structural issues, but instead taking part in actions that only continued to harm the community is not only disappointing, but you've helped to sow distrust in this community and feed attacks towards us actually working towards effective police oversight. I don't know what your true motivations and political aspirations are. What I do know though is that is not the way to create a healthier and safer community, at all.
There is a lot of anxiety and emotions around the DA's decision today. Our community is carrying real pain, frustration and justified anger and whatever decision is announced will impact people differently. However, whatever the DA's decision, our work in the city doesn't stop. The need for accountability, trust, safety and effective progress does not disappear, in the contrary it becomes even more relevant. And all of it is too important to be overshadowed by more drama, personal grievances, misleading claims, and efforts to turn people against one another. We must remain focussed on the work our community expects and deserves.
Correcting Untrue Statements About Me
- First, the questions I sent to the former interim independent monitor (IIM) were intended to give her an opportunity to respond and to ensure that the Common Council had her answers on the record to consider. She did not respond to those questions. That is very different from the suggestion that I was conducting some unauthorized investigation or attempting to orchestrate her removal.
- I have also been accused of working with police associations to obtain records before legal counsel advised that they could be released, potentially putting complainants at risk. That is false.
- I did not tell anyone that the OIPM had become about one case, Tony Robinson. I also did not receive confidential personnel information from Human Resources. These are not small differences of interpretation. They are claims about my actions and my integrity, and they are not true.
On the President's Workgroup
I established the President's Workgroup on Madison Police Department Use of Deadly Force, De-Escalation and Body-Worn Cameras Policies and Procedures.
The order is public, and I encourage folks to read it.
- The workgroup was established to study existing policies, review previous reports and recommendations, educate the Council, hold a public listening session, and make recommendations regarding police department policies and procedures. It is required to submit a final report and recommendations to the Common Council by March 30, 2027, and draft legislation to implement its recommendations.
- It was not established to undermine the work of the OIPM or PCOB.
- The IIM's claims are misleading and leaves out necessary context.
- The workgroup's meetings are public, and its work can be followed and reviewed by anyone.
Relevant links:
- President's Workgroup
- Past and upcoming meetings
- Questions to former IIM
- Employment Review of Interim Independent Monitor (IIM)
- IIM Job Posting
In community,
President Madison