Why all the main breaks?
posted
Repair crews deal with a string of main breaks across Madison
It's 5:00 a.m. on an usually warm February morning, and the call comes in – a six-inch wide water main has ruptured beneath busy Regent Street just off the UW Madison campus. The break is one of 11 in Madison in four days, and utility officials say the sudden warm-up is largely to blame.
"The soil expands and contracts as it freezes and as it thaws," explains Al Larson, principal engineer with Madison Water Utility, adding that aging mains are more vulnerable to soil movement caused by sudden swings in temperature. "For the older, more brittle mains – the ones that were built in the 30s, 40s and 50s – it gets to the point where they just can't take that force and break."
Much of Madison's water main infrastructure dates to the WWII and immediate postwar era, when pipes were made of a less durable material called spun cast iron. While the pipes have served the city well for more than six decades, they're now starting to show their age. Madison Water Utility crews generally repair more that 200 main breaks every year. In 2013, that number swelled to a record of 306 due to a combination of aging infrastructure and extreme winter weather. The record was broken again in 2014 with more than 339 breaks.
"The standard should be 20 breaks per hundred miles (of pipe). For us, that would be 170," Larson says.
And the Utility is undertaking an aggressive plan to get there.
Replacing and renewing
Over the next four decades, Madison Water Utility will replace nearly half its water mains, some 400 miles of pipe. It's an expensive goal – the Utility spent $7.5 million replacing water mains in 2013. By 2020, it will be spending around $12.7 million a year on main replacement and renewal.
"The other thing that we're doing is looking at new technologies like main lining," Larson points out. "The City of Madison was the first one in the state of Wisconsin to line a water main, and we're ramping that up significantly. The budget for water main lining is twice as big in 2014 as it was in 2013. In 3 or 4 years, it's going to double again. We're using new technology to be able to stretch our dollars as far as they can go."
Photo: Crews reline a water main on Madison's west side
Madison is far from alone when it comes to deteriorating water infrastructure. According to the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), much of the drinking water infrastructure across the country is in dire need of replacement. ASCE's "Report Card on America's Infrastructure" gives the country's overall water infrastructure a D grade. The report card notes that there are about 240,000 water main breaks every year in the United States.
Larson admits that despite all the breaks, Madison Water Utility doesn't necessarily have to pursue a plan of main replacement. It could simply focus on repairs.
"We could always repair. More workers, more equipment. We could always say, 'Three or four hundred breaks a year is okay. We're just going to live with it.' And we'll have a situation where City Engineering will go and rebuild a street, repave it in the summer, and the main will break in the winter, and we'll go out and dig up brand new streets."
Larson adds that in a climate like Wisconsin's, there will always be main breaks. But he insists it's the Utility's job to keep Madison's infrastructure in the very best shape possible, because the alternative is unacceptable.
"People are not going to want to see their street dug up every year, disrupted service. People just get to that tipping point and they say 'No more. We've got to do something.'"
Subscribe to Water Utility News & Alerts Updates
Archive
Category
Uncategorized
- A funny song about a serious thing
- Reminder: The Great Showerhead Giveaway happening this Saturday!
- Flushing program puts Madison "on the forefront"
- Paying for Progress
- The long road to smart meters
- Going in the hole: Madison Water Utility crews take on main break season
- Madison getting its first new water well in a decade
- Rebuilding pride in Paterson
- Lake View Reservoir reconstruction sparks neighborhood interest
- Madison Water Utility builds new water mains -- inside the old ones
- Well hunters: Finding Madison's long-hidden private wells
History
- What’s under Monroe Street?
- Finding Madison's foxes
- Bidding farewell to Madison’s “legacy” main
- Madison Water Utility turns 135!
- World War II-era journals discovered at construction site
- EPA seeks details of Madison’s Lead Service Replacement Program
- Rediscovering the reservoir
- Unearthing Madison's history
Our People
- Worst-case: What happens when a water main breaks under an airport taxiway?
- Imagine a Day Without Water
- High school students get hands-on training at MWU
- Worst winter ever? Lessons learned from the "polar vortex" winter of 2013-14
- Imagine a day without water
- MWU releases Annual Water Quality Report
- EPA seeks details of Madison’s Lead Service Replacement Program
- Madison women make history -- with a little help from their friends
- Sometimes, it's what you don't see
- MWU honored for winning Best-Tasting Water in the state!
- Wisconsin's first ever women's tapping team created at MWU
Serving the Community
- “Got Water?” project announces 2020 hydration station schools!
- Final segment of decade-long water main project underway
- Toilet Rebate Program hits 1 billion gallons of water saved!
- Worst-case: What happens when a water main breaks under an airport taxiway?
- Wild February weather takes toll on water mains
- “Got Water?” initiative reaches more than 11,000 students
- Imagine a Day Without Water
- Madison Water Utility adds first new well in more than a decade
- High school students get hands-on training at MWU
- Two Madison Water Utility projects getting national attention
- Imagine a Day Without Water
- What does your water dollar pay for?
- Partnership with Project Home making an impact
- What does your water dollar pay for?
- You can now register to vote at Madison Water Utility!
- Planned Blackhawk Water Tower signals growth on the far west side
- MWU invests millions in water infrastructure on northeast side
- Frozen on the inside: Indoor flooding season is here
- Madison Water Utility first in state to launch "ultimate conservation tool"
- The Water Wagon: A cool lesson in sustainability
- New downtown community garden takes root in unlikely spot
- East Johnson Street: No Ordinary Construction Zone
- Major public works project set to begin on north side
- When there's a fire: MWU's critical mission
- Wisconsin Water for the World: Making a difference one village at a time
- Blindsided: When drivers don't see work zones
- The winter that won't be forgotten
- Frozen on the inside: Indoor flooding season is here
- Bad Medicine
Sustainability
- Madison Water Utility reports unprecedented drop in city’s water use
- Final segment of decade-long water main project underway
- EVERY DROP MADISON poll closes soon!
- Average aquifer levels highest in a generation
- Toilet Rebate Program hits 1 billion gallons of water saved!
- Lost Lou and Peter Barryman tune about conservation gets new life.
- Flushing program puts Madison "on the forefront"
- Wild February weather takes toll on water mains
- Annual water use in Madison drops by a billion gallons in six years
- Madison Water Utility adds first new well in more than a decade
- A funny song about a serious thing
- Water use in Madison drops to lowest level in 50 years
- Catching catastrophic plumbing problems -- through email
- 100 miles of main
- Saving Madison from salt
- You have a voice! MWU seeks public input on critical water issues
- How low can we go?
- Why all the main breaks?
- Madison woman gets serious about water conservation, wins an iPad
- MWU customers catch plumbing leaks – online
- All eyes on the aquifer: Is Madison's water supply sustainable?
- Our graywater experiment: 10 years and counting
- Madison Water Utility first in state to launch "ultimate conservation tool"
- When winter's over: the lasting impact of road salt
- Why all the main breaks?
- Bad Medicine
- Our graywater experiment: 8 years and counting
Water quality
- "We'll be doing this forever." Understanding the impact of PFAS
- EVERY DROP MADISON poll closes soon!
- Imagine a Day Without Water
- Widely used chemicals detected in two Madison wells
- Saving Madison from salt
- Into the bore hole: Tackling the road salt problem at a west side well
- Saving Madison from salt
- Madisonians cite safety and conservation as top water issues
- Why add chlorine? The story behind water disinfection
- Water main flushing puts Madison "on the forefront"
- EPA looks to Madison as leader on lead pipe issue
- Saving Madison from salt
- No easy answers for Well 8
- As Safe Drinking Water Act turns 40, Madison ramps up testing
- Taking safety seriously: The story behind water chlorination
Tags
- aquifer
- Arbor Hills
- AWWA
- Barrymans
- Blackhawk
- Booster Pump Station 106
- CAP
- capitol
- chloride
- chlorine
- Clean Water
- Climate Change
- Common Council
- Community
- Conservation
- cost
- cost of water
- Customer Care
- Customer service
- disinfection
- drinking water
- Education
- efficiency
- energy
- engineering
- environment
- EPA
- Fire
- Fire protection
- Flooded houses
- freezing
- Frozen pipes
- Got Water
- Got Water?
- graywater
- Greywater
- healthy kids
- History
- hydration
- Imagine a Day Without Water
- Inclusive workplace
- Infrastructure
- John Heim
- John Muir
- Lake View Hill
- lakes
- lead pipes
- lead service replacement program
- leaks
- Lou and Peter
- Lou and Peter Barryman
- Low Income
- Mad City Tappers
- Mad Women on Tap
- Madison
- Madison City Channel
- Madison Kipp
- Madison Municipal Services
- Madison Water
- Madison Water Utility
- Main breaks
- Michael Edmonds
- MWU
- New well
- North Madison
- O'Dea
- Operation center
- Paterson
- Perfluorinated compounds
- PFAS
- pipes
- Placemaking
- plumbing
- Private Wells
- Project H2O
- Project Home
- Projects
- Public Works
- pumping
- Recycled water
- Remucal
- Reservoir Park
- Road Salt
- Safety
- shower
- Southeast
- stormwater
- study
- Survey
- Sustainability
- Tap Water
- Tapping Team
- TeamCity
- Technology
- Testing
- Testing
- Toilet Rebate
- UW
- UW Madison
- Wanda Fullmore Youth Internship Program
- water
- water bill
- Water board
- Water conservation
- Water Main
- Water main flushing
- Water Mains
- Water Quality
- Water Quality Report
- water safety
- Water supply
- Water Tower
- Water Utility
- Water Wagon
- Water Works
- WaterSense
- watershed
- Well 14
- Well 31
- Well 8
- Wellhead Protection
- West Madison
- west side
- Winter
- Winter Safety
- Winterization
- WiSaltWise
- Women's
- Women's History Month
- World War II
- WWA